Last November a guy I know who owns an HVAC company ran the biggest promotion in his company’s history. Fifteen percent off every system replacement booked in November, with the big push on Black Friday. Radio spots, a postcard drop, a banner across the top of his website. His phones lit up like it was the first heat wave of July.

He sold sixty installs that month. The November before, he’d sold forty. His average job went from about $10,000 to about $8,500 after the discount, and his revenue for the month jumped from $400,000 to $510,000. Best month he ever had. He took his whole team out for steaks.

In January his accountant sat him down and showed him the other number.

His gross profit for November was down thirty thousand dollars from the year before.

His crews worked fifty percent more jobs. They ran overtime the week before Christmas. Two of his best techs were burned out by New Year’s. And he made less money than he did the year he didn’t run a promotion at all.

“I felt like I’d been robbed,” he told me. “Except I robbed myself, and I bought the guys steaks to celebrate it.”

The Math Almost Nobody Does

Here’s what happened, and it’s going to happen to a lot of business owners in the next two weeks.

His installs ran at about a thirty percent gross margin. On a $10,000 job, that’s $7,000 in equipment, labor, and materials, and $3,000 in gross profit. When he knocked fifteen percent off, the price dropped to $8,500. But the cost didn’t drop at all. Same equipment. Same crew. Same truck. Same permit.

So his gross profit per job went from $3,000 to $1,500. He cut his price fifteen percent and cut his profit per job in half.

To make the same money as the year before, he didn’t need fifty percent more jobs. He needed twice as many. Eighty installs instead of forty. He never had a shot.

There’s a simple formula for this, and every owner should have it taped to his monitor before Black Friday:

Extra volume you need to break even = discount ÷ (your gross margin minus the discount)

At a thirty percent margin, a fifteen percent discount means 15 divided by 15. One hundred percent more volume. Double the work for the same money.

Here’s what that looks like across the margins most of you run:

Your gross margin

5% off

10% off

15% off

20% off

30%

20% more

50% more

100% more

200% more

40%

14% more

33% more

60% more

100% more

50%

11% more

25% more

43% more

67% more

Read the top right corner of that table again. If you run a thirty percent margin and you put twenty percent off on a banner, you need three times the volume to make the same money. Not ten percent more. Three times.

Most of you don’t have the crews, the trucks, or the hours to triple anything in December. Which means for most of you, a big discount isn’t a growth strategy. It’s a pay cut you give yourself in public.

Price Is the Biggest Lever You Own

There’s an old study from McKinsey that every pricing consultant on earth quotes, and for good reason. Michael Marn and Robert Rosiello looked at the economics of about 2,400 companies and published what they found in the Harvard Business Review. For the average company in their data, a one percent improvement in price, with volume holding steady, raised operating profit by about eleven percent.

A one percent increase in volume, on the other hand, raised operating profit by just over three percent.

Now flip it around. If one percent on price is worth about eleven percent of your operating profit, then every point you knock off is coming straight out of the money you actually keep. Your numbers won’t match theirs exactly. But the direction is the same in almost every business, and it’s why the guys who protect their price tend to quietly outearn the guys who run the loudest promotions.

Why Discounts Hurt Service Businesses the Most

If you sell televisions, Black Friday makes a certain kind of sense. The store has thousands of units, the manufacturer helps pay for the discount, and the doorbuster gets people in to buy a cable that’s marked up four hundred percent.

You’re not Best Buy. You sell hours, crews, and expertise, and you’ve only got so many of each. Here’s what a discount actually does to a business like yours.

It mostly gives money to people who were going to buy anyway. Half of that HVAC owner’s November customers had old systems that were going to get replaced that winter regardless. He paid them $1,500 each to do what they were already going to do.

It fills your schedule with your least profitable work. When your crews are booked solid with discounted jobs, they’re not available for the full price emergency call that comes in on December 19.

It teaches your customers to wait. Run fifteen percent off every November and your customers will learn to hold off until November. Your slow season gets slower and your busy season gets less profitable.

It attracts the wrong buyers. The customer who comes for the discount leaves for the next discount. The customer who comes for the work stays for twenty years.

It becomes the new price. Once somebody’s paid $8,500, try charging them $10,000 next time and see how that conversation goes.

Know Your Margin Before You Touch Your Price

You can’t run any of this math if you don’t know your gross margin, and a surprising number of owners don’t. They know revenue. They know roughly what’s in the bank account. They don’t know what they actually keep on a typical job.

Here’s the quick version. Take your revenue for the last twelve months. Subtract everything it took to deliver the work. Materials, equipment, subcontractors, the wages and payroll taxes of the people who actually do the work, job site costs. Whatever’s left is gross profit. Divide it by revenue. That’s your gross margin.

Then do it for your three most common jobs individually. You’ll almost always find one that’s a lot less profitable than you thought. That’s the last thing in your business you should ever discount.

Add, Don’t Subtract

Here’s the move that changes everything. Instead of taking money off the price, put value on top of it.

When you give a customer fifteen percent off, it costs you fifteen percent of the price in cash, dollar for dollar. When you give them something extra, it costs you only what that thing costs you to deliver, but the customer values it at what it would cost them to buy.

Back to our HVAC owner. Instead of $1,500 off a $10,000 install, he could have thrown in a two year maintenance plan. He sells that plan for $400 a year, so to the customer it’s an $800 gift. It costs him maybe $250 in labor and parts to deliver over two years. And it puts his techs in that customer’s house four more times, where they’ll spot the water heater that’s about to go and the duct work that needs sealing.

Same Black Friday energy. One sixth of the cost. Plus four more chances to earn the next job.

Here are a few ways to add instead of subtract:

  • A bonus service. A free tune up, a free inspection, a free first month of maintenance.

  • An upgrade. The better thermostat, the premium finish, the longer warranty, at the standard price.

  • Priority. First on the schedule, guaranteed response times, a direct line to a senior tech.

  • A bundle. Two services together that are worth more than either one alone.

  • Future value. A credit good for next spring, which also fills your slow season. You saw how this works in the gift card math a few weeks back.

If You’re Going to Discount, Make Them Earn It

Sometimes a discount is the right call. When it is, never give it away for nothing. Trade it for something you want.

Trade it for timing. Discount the work you’d otherwise have no work for. If January is dead, a discount on jobs scheduled in the third week of January is a smart trade. You’re filling idle capacity, not giving away capacity you’d have sold anyway.

Trade it for cash up front. A small discount for payment in full in advance. You get the cash now, and you never have to chase an invoice.

Trade it for commitment. A better rate for a two year agreement instead of one. A better rate for a bigger scope.

Trade it for scope. If the customer needs a lower number, take something out. “I can get to that number if we skip the new ductwork and keep the existing returns.” Price goes down, but so does your cost.

Put a fence around it. A real deadline. A real limit. A real reason. “We’re holding six January install slots at this rate” is a strategy. “Fifteen percent off everything until whenever” is a fire sale.

When They Ask, “Can You Do Better on Price?”

This one question costs owners more money than any recession. Here’s how to handle it without folding.

Get comfortable with silence. When somebody asks if you can do better, the worst thing you can do is answer immediately. Wait a beat. Then ask, “What did you have in mind?” Half the time it’s a reflex question and the answer is “I don’t know, I just figured I’d ask.”

Hold the line and explain why. “That’s our price. It includes the permit, the cleanup, and a ten year labor warranty. A lot of quotes you’ll see don’t. I’d rather be clear with you up front than surprise you later.”

Trade instead of cave. “I can’t move on the price, but if timing is flexible, I can get you in the second week of January at a better rate.”

Take something out. “If the number is the most important thing, let’s look at what we can take off the scope to get you there.”

Notice the one move that isn’t on that list. Cutting the price with nothing in return. Once you do that, you’ve told the customer your first number wasn’t real. Every number after it will be negotiated too.

Find Out Where Your Discounts Are Hiding

Here’s the uncomfortable part. Even if you never run a Black Friday sale, you’re probably already discounting. You just don’t see it.

The salesperson who knocks off $300 to close the deal faster. The office manager who waives the trip charge because the customer complained. The project manager who gives the friend of a friend a deal. Every one of those feels small in the moment. Add them up for a year and you’ll probably be sick.

So set two rules.

Rule one, discount authority in writing. Who can give a discount, how much, and under what conditions. Anything over that limit needs your approval. Same idea as approving checks above a certain amount.

Rule two, every discount gets logged. I set this up in Make in about an hour. Every time an invoice or estimate goes out with a discount line on it, Make pulls the customer, the job, the amount, and who gave it, and drops it into one row of a Google Sheet. Every Friday morning it sends me a total for the week. The first time I saw that number, I changed three policies before lunch.

What gets measured gets managed. What gets logged gets a lot smaller.

What to Do This Black Friday Instead

If you want to make some noise on Black Friday, here’s how to do it without lighting your margin on fire.

Go to your best customers first. Send your existing customers an offer a few days before anybody else sees it. Not a discount. A bonus. “Book before December 15 and we’ll add a free maintenance visit in the spring.”

Make it about the add. Put the value on the banner, not the percent. “Free two year maintenance plan with every install” sells just as well as fifteen percent off, and it costs a fraction as much.

Cap it. Limit the number of slots. Scarcity is real when you’ve only got so many crews, so say so.

Run the numbers before you launch. Use the formula. Know exactly how many extra jobs you’d need for any discount to pay for itself. If you don’t have the capacity to do that many, don’t run it.

The Bigger Point

A discount feels like generosity. It feels like you’re doing your customer a favor, and in a season built around giving, that feels good.

But real generosity is something you choose on purpose, with your own money, for the people you choose. What most owners do in late November isn’t generosity. It’s giving away margin by accident, because a competitor put up a banner and they got nervous.

Charge what the work is worth. Then, if you want to be generous, be generous on purpose. We’ll talk about that on Sunday.

Today’s Move

Before Black Friday:

  1. Calculate your gross margin, for the business overall and for your three most common jobs.

  2. Run every discount you’re considering through the formula. Write down how many extra jobs each one would need.

  3. Swap one discount for an add. Pick the bonus that costs you the least and is worth the most to your customer.

  4. Write your discount authority rule and send it to everyone who quotes or invoices.

WANT THE WHOLE KIT?

Reply to this email with the word MARGIN and I’ll send you The Discount Math Field Kit. It has the break even volume table for every margin from 20 to 60 percent, the job margin calculator, the value add menu with 30 bonus ideas sorted by industry, the give to get discount rules, the “can you do better on price” scripts word for word, a one page discount authority policy you can sign today, and the step by step Make setup for your discount ledger.

Charge what the work is worth. Then be generous on purpose.

Friday we’re talking about the other way money walks out the door. Not the discount you give at the start of a job. The free work you do in the middle of it, one “while you’re here” at a time.

Refined. Relentless. Unapologetic.

Marcus